WAN-IFRA

A publication of the World Editors Forum

Date

Thu - 23.05.2013


March 2007

In the wake of the “guest editor” scandal that led to Los Angeles Times Current (op/ed page) editor Andrés Martinez to resign, American Journalism Review editor Rem Rieder has offered his opinion on why guest editors don't mix with sound journalism.

Martinez had planned a Sunday Current section guest-edited by Hollywood producer Brian Grazer. However, it was revealed that Martinez dates the vice president of the PR firm that represents Grazer, a relationship that was too close for the Times’ comfort and resulted in the publisher’s canceling the special section completely.

Rieder says that, though journalism needs new voices right now, allowing amateurs (even buzz-creating celebrities) undermines the difficulty and importance of an editor’s job. Though journalism isn’t perfect, he says, professional journalists generally at least strive toward certain ethical standards.

Further, Rieder points out the potential conflict of interest of a newspapers’ working directly with those they cover. Martinez had planned to have Donald Rumsfeld and Magic Johnson as future guest editors.

“I don't know about you,” Rieder says, “but I'm not eager to fly on the first airline to offer up a ‘guest pilot’ program.

Author

Lindsay Berrigan

Date

2007-03-27 16:12

The World Association of Newspapers (WAN) 2007 World Young Reader Conference and Expo, called “Making New Connections”, is currently underway in Washington, DC.

The conference began yesterday and goes until tomorrow, bringing together 400 participants from 74 countries to fight newspapers’ decline among young readers and discuss strategies, both in print and online, that newspapers use to increase youth readership.

WAN awarded the World Young Reader Newspaper of the Year prize to the Times of India during a ceremony yesterday. In addition to taking the top award, The Times was also awarded the World Young Reader Prize in the Newspapers in Education category, which honored its effective use of the newspaper as a teaching tool.

"Reading & Learning," a series of Newspapers in Education (NIE) guides that target diversity as a core element of NIE, has also been unveiled at the conference. The three-part series includes guides for newspaper executives, NIE coordinators and teachers. The guides, in English or Spanish, are available by request to nie@wan.asso.fr.

Tags

Author

Lindsay Berrigan

Date

2007-03-27 15:39

The Knight Citizen News Network (KCNN) launched today. It is a free web portal designed to help citizens and journalists learn how to create and operate community news websites.

KCNN was created to help both citizen journalists and professionals. The portal aims to “help citizens use digital media in ways that enrich community, enhance public discourse and enliven democracy,” reports J-lab, which manages KCNN.org. But KCNN also “seeks to open doors for traditional news organizations seeking to embrace user-generated content.”

In a way, KCNN embraces new and traditional media convergence: it aims to teach professional practices to citizens and incorporate more user-generated content in professional journalism.

The site will offer a few key resources, useful to both citizens and professionals:

- database of US citizen journalism websites
- Editorial selection of “Things We Like” among US news websites
- Interviews about citizen journalism
- Reasearch and case studies to train citizen journalists

The site was funded by a grant from the Knight Foundation and was developed with the contributions of prominent new media figures such as Amy Gahran, Adam Glenn and Dan Gillmor.

Source: J-lab through Ifra Executive News Service

Tags

Author

Jean Yves Chainon

Date

2007-03-27 14:00

A book released today, "News, Improved: How America's Newsrooms Are Learning to Change" written by Tim Porter and Michele McLellan and funded by the John S. and James L. Knight Foundation, aims to teach newsrooms how to innovate.

"We have a model of leadership that's set up for a static industry, and right now we're in a very dynamic and changing one," says McLellan. “News, Improved” suggests a solution: strategic training, training that educates entire staffs toward specific goals while carefully measuring success and failure.

In 2002, a Knight survey of journalists found that eight in 10 journalists wanted more training than they were getting; now, the number has increased to nine in 10. The new survey also shows that journalists want specific, practical training, such as sessions on how to use multimedia storytelling tools. They also prefer training to occur outside the newsroom.

"The news industry trains people as badly as a fast-food diet nourishes them," the authors write. "Training is episodic rather than continuous. Random, rather than strategic. Long on talk. Short on measurable impact."

For the past four years, Knight has funded the Newsroom Training Initiative, consisting of six specific training programs including one online distance-learning project.

Author

Lindsay Berrigan

Date

2007-03-27 13:10

Not only the TV, the radio or the internet can be successful. To have a brilliant future, newspapers must become more interactive and promote the right of citizens to participate, said one of the editors of “El Correo” Newspaper, Monserrat Lluis. She won last week the “Young Readers” Prize of the World Association of Newspapers (WAN).

Lluis went in September 2005 to the last “World Young Reader Conference” in Buenos Aires (Argentina) searching for new ideas for her newspaper, El Correo (Spain). After that, she has led an important transformation process: now, not only has the number of young readers increased; their participation in the different pages and sections of the newspaper is significant.

Before this revolutionary renovation, El Correo used to receive about 30 readers´ collaborations per day. Now, there are 500. Instead of only leaving a few pages to the readers, such as “the typical mailbox of letters to the Director,” the journalists provide a face and personality to animate the discussion, to participate and respond. “We have decided to open to the readers almost all sections of our newspaper”, said Lluis. The readers have about 30 places in the newspaper where they can send letters, articles, photos, etc.

Tags

Author

Manuel Mantilla

Date

2007-03-27 12:52

This morning brought news that further convinced bloggers of print’s demise; 30-year-old magazine InfoWorld confirmed rumors that the publication will become digital-only in April. Newspaper industry insiders, however, don’t agree.

Jason Lee Miller of Web Pro News responded to naysaying bloggers today by interviewing some insiders and by compiling his own list of 10 reasons why print’s not dead.

David Greer, Member Services Director for the Kentucky Press Association, said that in his home state, small local papers’ circulations are up. “Content is still king,” he said. If you have the content then the platform you have to distribute that content is still secondary."

In the US, newspapers thrive in small communities, where people remain loyal to the local paper. Small papers contain news about local people and issues close to the hearts of residents. Online news usually cannot provide this intimacy.

In February, Pew Internet and American Life Project released a study showing that most of those polled still preferred newspapers to reading news online or on other media platforms. People preferred the tactile, leisurely experience of reading an actual paper.

Author

Lindsay Berrigan

Date

2007-03-27 12:25

As the Web increasingly fosters original – sometimes inaccurate – content, traditional media tend to reproduce it unknowingly to ride the wave of popularity. This also poses a new challenge to traditional journalism’s accuracy.

Newspapers have traditionally been, and still are, content providers, whereas online news websites have been content distributors – outlets rather than sources. As this changes, traditional media must exercise extra caution.

An anti-Hillary Clinton video posted on YouTube last week demonstrated this effect, as the video quickly spread to network broadcasts such as NBC and CBS.

It turned out that the video’s author worked for a consulting firm that serviced competing candidate Barack Obama. But traditional media outlets had already widely reproduced this as ‘news’.

Online, "you essentially have a public wall where anybody can put up a billboard and say anything," says Tom Rosenstiel, director of the Project for Excellence in Journalism. "And if the wall attracts a crowd, mainstream media write about it."

The surge of online sources presents a challenge for traditional media, which must gauge the accuracy of sometimes unverifiable content.

"If something is out there and having an impact, you probably have a responsibility to report it. But you have no less a responsibility to tell me if it's believable or not," says Rosenstiel.

Tags

Author

Jean Yves Chainon

Date

2007-03-27 11:43

Broadcast newsrooms are using flexible new software and methods to restructure and distribute content to many platforms without hiring new staff to do so; since many newspapers are looking to do the same; here is some specific software advice from Broadcasting & Cable.

“The newsroom system now has to be able to support RSS feeds and broadcasting to mobile phones. You have more and more distribution methods, but customers want to use the same amount of people, if not less," says Johnathon Howard, director of on-air product management for software company Avid.

Some recent, print journalist-friendly innovations are:

- Avid Active Content Manager – Allows user to separate content from display, so one can write once but publish to several websites or mobile phone platforms

-Apple Final Cut Studio – Editing and graphics software, allows user to repurpose a piece of content for the web, podcasts, etc.

- Vizrt Viz-Multi-Platform Suite – Links with Vizrt’s broadcast-graphics tools, delivers real-time graphics and video to the Web and mobile devices. May provide opportunity to deliver advertising as well as news graphics.

- Chyron WAPSTR System – Allows user to upload still images and videos from mobile phones directly to a newsroom. Useful for bringing in user-generated content.

Tags

Author

Lindsay Berrigan

Date

2007-03-27 11:22

Many months of speculation about the future of newspapers culminated in September 2006 with a front-page story by The Economist asking: “Who killed the newspaper?” To gain an insiders view of this morbid forecast, the World Editors Forum and Reuters launched an initiative to probe those most concerned: editors-in-chief, deputy editors and senior news executives.

One may have thought them to be morose, discouraged and overwhelmed by the evolution of technology, but in the first Newsroom Barometer - conducted by Zogby International - ever carried out, they proved to be just the opposite: 85% of senior news executives see a rosy future for their newspaper. They accept competition from online sources and free papers, and in turn are making efforts to adapt to the 21st century readership.

Tags

Author

Jean Yves Chainon

Date

2007-03-27 10:27

In the Newsroom Barometer, three questions revolved around editors’ views about the new challenges and opportunities for newspapers that have emerged with new forms of journalism, such as free papers, citizen journalism and online news. Far from resenting these forms, senior news executives embraced them.

This is perhaps one of the most important findings of the Newsroom Barometer: all the talk about newspapers and news executives being scared of new media, citizen journalism and user-generated content was misplaced.

What best describes your view of free newspapers and their place in your market?

Instead of fearing the competition of citizen journalism, the vast majority of editors welcome it (79%, see question 2). Perhaps more significantly, only 5% of respondents view new media journalism as a threat. More editors than not now consider free papers as ‘real’ newspapers, as part of the transition towards the audience’s changing habits.

Respondents from large newspapers (200k+ circulation) were much less concerned about free papers as a threat (21%), compared to those from smaller papers (<200k: 32%). Large newspapers simply have the resources to fight off free paper competition, or even produce their own version.
Although the free paper model emerged in Norway and Sweden, respondents from Western Europe, which have a long tradition of paid-for dailies, were more likely to view free papers as a threat, 42%, while other world regions welcomed the emergence of freesheets.

Tags

Author

Jean Yves Chainon

Date

2007-03-27 10:14

The Newsroom Barometer also probed editors’ own predictions for the future of their newspapers and the newspaper industry. Again, unlike talks about news executives’ rigid conservatism, the study revealed editors were realistic in their assessment. Online will be the most common platform within 10 years, news will mostly be free, and opinion and in-depth commentary will increase in importance.

Do you think that the majority of news (print and online) will be free in the future?

In this period of upheaval for the newspaper industry’s platforms and methods, respondents were split, but a significant majority, 48%, believed that news will follow its current trend and that most of it would eventually be free (39% didn’t). The future of paid-for daily model is clearly put into question, even by those who produce it.

Tags

Author

Jean Yves Chainon

Date

2007-03-27 09:54

The Newsroom Barometer also gave editors and senior news executives a chance to reveal their priorities within the newsroom. Most (innovative) editors wanted to retrain their journalists in new media, although a good share also stuck to traditional strategies such as hiring more journalists.

If you had to invest in editorial quality, what would you do first in the newsroom?

Across all categories, the responses illustrated how necessary modernization has become for the newspaper industry: the answer by 36% of the respondents was to train their staff in new media, loosely followed by more journalist recruits, at 23%.
Smaller papers (circulation <200k), while slightly less focused on new media, still prioritized it 34% of the time. Larger newspapers, with a circulation of 200K+, put even more emphasis on new media, 41%, presumably because digital activities have long been recognized as the fastest-growing assets and the strategic focus for cross-platform multimedia companies.
South and North America were the most focused on new media (47% and 46% respectively). Asia and Western Europe, usually considered as proponents of new media, were surprisingly below average (31% and 35% respectively) – they were concerned with ‘old-fashioned’ solutions, such as retraining journalists in ‘traditional skills’ (Asia) or recruiting more reporters (Western Europe).

If you had to invest in editorial quality, what would you do second in the newsroom?

Tags

Author

Jean Yves Chainon

Date

2007-03-27 09:44

435 senior news executives from around the world answered the Newsroom Barometer (there are 10,000 daily newspapers worldwide). The respondents participated in the survey on the Zogby International website, and, on the whole, were representative of editors worldwide.

The survey span across two months, from October 8 through December 7 2006, after the World Editors Forum sent an email to its database of 6,000 editors There were 480 responses and 45 were discarded, based on the fact that the respondent didn’t qualify as a senior news executive.

So who were the respondents?

435 senior news executives from around the world answered the Newsroom Barometer (there are 10,000 daily newspapers worldwide). These included editors-in-chief (45%), managing editors (17%) and other types of news executives across the board.

Most of them were over 50 years of age (40%), but this means that younger editors and news executives were also represented.

For this first edition of the Newsroom Barometer, the geographic distribution of respondents was less representative of worldwide views, with 42% coming from Western Europe, 14% from Asia and 9% from North America, but this gave an in-depth view of the newspaper market in the ‘Old World’.

Tags

Author

Jean Yves Chainon

Date

2007-03-27 09:29

In this section, John Zogby, CEO of Zogby International, and Jeff Jarvis, new media proponent and founder of Buzzmachine, comment on the results of the Newsroom Barometer. Both found that editors’ optimism and open-mindedness to new media was a clear indication that newspapers were embracing the digital revolution, yet Jarvis fears that may not be enough…

Indeed, Jarvis believes “one of the biggest threats to the future of newspapers is not the internet, Craig’s List, or freesheets but, indeed, some editors themselves – those who have resisted change and missed so many of the opportunities technology provides to expand journalism.”

One of the main challenges in the evolution will be to let go of a traditional and well-respected medium, paper. “It is time to go the next step, to stop defining ourselves by our medium, paper, and to start defining ourselves by our service: journalism,” says Jarvis.

So Jarvis points towards the obvious, but essential, realization that newspapers now sell a professional service, accurate content, rather than a package (although they sell the package too).

Tags

Author

Jean Yves Chainon

Date

2007-03-27 09:08

According to the Wall Street Journal Online, Tribune Co. is poised to accept a buyout proposal from real-estate tycoon Sam Zell.

This would give Zell control of several major newspapers including the LA Times and the Chicago Tribune, 23 television stations, and the Chicago Cubs baseball team.

A committee is scheduled to meet late this week to make a decision. A mere week ago, Zell’s offer looked ready to fall flat, as the committee expressed worry over the amount of debt involved in the plan. Zell in turn added more money to the plan, bringing the total cash portion to $300 million.

Even if Tribune Co. accepts the offer, the logistics of the deal could complicate matters. Tribune Co. has exemption from the Federal Communications Commission allowing them to own TV stations and newspapers in the same markets, something not guaranteed to a new owner. Further, Tribune Co. is already in debt and may have trouble withstanding larger debts incurred in the buyout.

Tags

Author

Lindsay Berrigan

Date

2007-03-26 18:03

Richard Riordan, mayor of Los Angeles from 1993 to 2001, has criticized the LA Times’ day-to-day presentation and content.

Riordan said that the front page and its feature column are “badly laid out and boring”, the Iraq coverage “repetitive,” and news stories often irrelevant. Above all, he criticizes Tribune Co., the owners of the Times, for cutting staff and allowing quality to suffer in recent years. In reaction to the presence of a new editor from Chicago, Riordan said, "We miss having a cheerleader, who brings all of the pieces in the city together."

To be fair, Riordan also called the Times a “very 1970’s liberal newspaper” and said that the paper had not been fair to him during his tenure. Riordan even once considered creating a paper to rival the Times, eventually abandoning the project. Though it’s hard to tell how much of his criticism comes from this resentment, it echoes that of media critics, who say that the staff cuts come at a time when the Times and all newspapers need to concentrate on generating quality content to keep circulation up.

Source: MarketWatch through Ifra Executive News Service

Author

Lindsay Berrigan

Date

2007-03-26 17:29

On Friday March 23, the Glasgow Evening Times for the first time used a photo taken by a reader on its front page.
Reader Paul O’Brien caught the image of a woman being rescued from a river by a military helicopter on his mobile phone and sent it to the Times, which used to photo on its website as well as print edition.

Though no Times photographers were at the scene, the paper still had six photos to choose from, all taken on readers’ phones and emailed to the Times. Photo editor John Young said that though the picture quality was not perfect, “With a news picture it's sometimes content rather than quality that matters."

As citizen journalism has generally remained an online phenomenon, newspapers often include user-generated content only on their websites. However, the inclusion of reader content in print editions, let alone on the front page, is a sure sign of further convergence of professional and amateur journalism. This could perhaps provide both a new venue for pro-am journalism and a new life for print.

Source: Online Press Gazette through Ifra Executive News Service

Tags

Author

Lindsay Berrigan

Date

2007-03-26 16:00

As video news on the Web gains popularity, newspapers are realizing that they can benefit greatly from allowing their journalists to get creative with online video –an expert recently gave some tips to Media Guardian on how newspapers can move forward in the video revolution.

Michael Rosenblum is a former New York Times executive who now runs a consultancy practice that provides video journalism training all over the world. Rosenblum believes that newspapers are perfectly positioned to make online video work to their advantage since TV thus far has kept its focus on its own programming, leaving the Internet for “leftover material.”

Rosenblum said that since print reporters are used to working alone and thinking on their feet, they have a further advantage over TV reporters in web video production, as TV reporters usually work with large crews involving much setup.

He offered some advice on how newspapers can best harness these advantages.

-Avoid “televisionization”- Don’t attempt to imitate broadcast news, but instead to integrate multimedia content to produce a new kind of storytelling.

-Build more interactive Flash elements and on-screen players directly into webpages to avoid pop-ups and keep video user-friendly.

Tags

Author

Lindsay Berrigan

Date

2007-03-26 15:23

University of Chicago economist Matthew Gentzkow recently completed a study showing that political bias at newspapers is driven by economics, not internal ideologies.

Gentzkow began his “What Drives Media Slant?” study, done with associate Jesse M. Shapiro, by analyzing the words used in the 2005 Congressional Record and matching words used with party membership. For example, a Republican usually calls a “death tax” what a Democrat calls an “estate tax.” With these findings, they then analyzed the words used in news articles in over 400 dailies, rating each one on a partisanship scale from Republican to Democrat.

Then, they looked at their research alongside analyses of campaign donations in each paper’s area. They found that newspaper bias in fact matches up with that of the audience. According to Gentzkow’s findings, newspapers assumed to be biased are just giving audiences what they want, rather than pushing forward their own ideologies. Along with many other components of news, newspaper bias is becoming increasingly determined by attempts to increase circulation and revenue.

Source: Editor & Publisher through Ifra Executive News Service

Author

Lindsay Berrigan

Date

2007-03-26 12:50

Columnist David Lazarus of the San Francisco Gate recently defended his position that newspapers should charge for online content against the host of bloggers who attacked him.

Lazarus’ disputed column suggested that newspapers could successfully charge for online content if they could come together in doing so. To do this, newspapers would have to lobby Congress for exemption antitrust laws. Lazarus sees newspapers at the edge of a "life-or-death struggle" and thinks the exemption could halp them into the digital age.

He sticks by his story in the new column, adding Fred Schiff, associate professor of communication at the University of Houston's idea of the newspaper website as a sort of virtual marketplace where free news will be a lure surrounded by ads and offers.

Many bloggers and citizen journalists responded with the idea that online content is not worth paying for and that charging for online content will turn readers off.

Tags

Author

Lindsay Berrigan

Date

2007-03-26 11:48

At the Changing Media Summit in London, Guardian editor Alan Rusbridger predicted that user-generated content would continue to grow to take on a preeminent role in journalism, but alongside traditional reporting.

"We are grappling with this balance of what goes on to the website and what goes in the paper. A great part of that web[content] will be generated by users in time," he said.

While saying this, he also reassured traditional journalists worried by this evolution, saying that "the role of journalists in this multi-media age has not changed and that user-generated content will only be a compliment to their work.”

"There is still a role for people to find things out. But to have people sat in a newsroom in Wapping or Farringdon Road thinking they know everything is barmy.”

In fact, in declaring that user-generated content would grow, Rusbridger was pointing at some kind of a pro-am journalist evolution, in which professional journalists could use the resources from amateurs.

"The smart journalists are working out ways of using that [user generated content]."

Rusbridger also mentioned that it is "impossible to predict on what technology platform journalism will be delivered in five years' time or even a year."

Source: Press Gazette through Ifra Executive News service

Tags

Author

Jean Yves Chainon

Date

2007-03-23 13:51

These two ideas are unrelated, but they can help to pull in readers at low cost. In its Sunday editions, The San Diego Union-Tribune offered football tickets for the playoffs. On the other side of the spectrum, USA Today included in its redesign a reporter index, which lists all reporters and offers a one-click access to their profile or all of their stories.

Between Dec. 31 and Jan.14, the Union-Tribune offered a pair of tickets to see the Chargers during the playoffs, within single-copy newspapers. Home subscribers could also get a chance to win tickets by filling out entry forms.

"The idea is to do fewer [promotions] in a bigger way," says George Bonaros, consumer marketing manager.

If your town isn’t big on football, there is certainly some kind of popular social event that people would be willing to spend a dollar on for a chance to participate – and read the paper.

Among USA Today’s new features is a user-friendly reporter index, which lists all journalists alphabetically. From the index, the user can access the reporter’s personal profile, or read all of his or her stories in one simple click.

Tags

Author

Jean Yves Chainon

Date

2007-03-23 13:33

Phillipe Val, editor of satirical French weekly Charlie Hebdo, was acquitted on Thursday after being sued by two Muslim groups for reprinting three of the infamous Danish cartoons depicting the Prophet Mohammed.

The Paris Grande Mosque and the Union of Islamic Organizations of France sued Val, saying that the images drew an offensive link between Muslims and terrorism.

The court ruled that two of the cartoons were absolutely not offensive, and that one had the potential to offend but was published in a purely humorous context.

Source: AFP Mail

Author

Lindsay Berrigan

Date

2007-03-23 10:03

Duncan Guy, a reporter for the South Africa Press Association, has started a free email newspaper of top news stories written in easy-to-understand language for children. The paper now goes out to 700 addresses twice a week.

Developed with feedback from teachers, each issue carries one story from each of five basic news categories: world news, African news, environmental news, business, and sports.

Each edition contains both the stories in “kidspeak” and the adult wire copy, for which difficult words are highlighted and explained in a glossary.

The paper comes in two versions: The Times I Am Living In and the Afrikaans translation Die Tyd Waarin Ek Leef.

Guy first created the newspaper for his son, then presented it to his son’s school. He now distributes to students of over 300 schools.

He does not avoid major issues, but rather puts a positive spin on negative events. For example, he wrote about the war in the Ivory Coast through a story of a boy reunited with his family.

The paper also holds cartoon competitions, with Guy himself visiting schools to deliver the prizes. The paper follows successful production of children’s papers in South America and France.

Author

Lindsay Berrigan

Date

2007-03-23 09:59


© 2013 WAN-IFRA - World Association of Newspapers and News Publishers

Footer Navigation