Opinion: Where do we draw the line with outsourcing?
Posted by Katherine Thompson on July 8, 2008 at 10:43 AM
Dave Stancliffe, a columnist at The Eureka Reporter in the USA, has published a unilateral condemnation of outsourcing. He asks: where do we draw the line with outsourcing?
Outsourcing may begin with ad production and layout, but where will the financiers look to next in their drive for efficiency? Is this the beginning of a wholesale move in search of cheaper labour, or is it a one-off reaction to a competitive market?
"I dread to see what will be outsourced next. Newspaper editors perhaps? Somewhere along the line we're losing more than just jobs," writes Stancliffe, citing issues of diminishing public trust if their local papers are edited overseas.
This is a serious question, especially for local newspapers. Pulitzer Prize-winning local newspaper, The Orange County Register, outsourced its copy editing and page design function to India after struggling with falling ad revenues. As Stancliffe writes, "The writing was on the wall in 2006 when they started offering a voluntary severance program."
If a paper is being copy-edited in another country, can it really still be called a "local newspaper"?
However, the wholesale relocation of newspapers to India or any other country is still unlikely. Most newspaper owners are well aware that to provide news to their communities they have to be a part of those communities. Running a newspaper is difficult enough without having to consider time-zone differences when chasing a story.
Early reports on outsourcing indicate that it is not always plane sailing. However, we will have to wait and see how these newspapers fare in their efficiency drive. Maybe this innovation will prove successful.
Source: The Eureka Reporter
Outsourcing may begin with ad production and layout, but where will the financiers look to next in their drive for efficiency? Is this the beginning of a wholesale move in search of cheaper labour, or is it a one-off reaction to a competitive market?
"I dread to see what will be outsourced next. Newspaper editors perhaps? Somewhere along the line we're losing more than just jobs," writes Stancliffe, citing issues of diminishing public trust if their local papers are edited overseas.
This is a serious question, especially for local newspapers. Pulitzer Prize-winning local newspaper, The Orange County Register, outsourced its copy editing and page design function to India after struggling with falling ad revenues. As Stancliffe writes, "The writing was on the wall in 2006 when they started offering a voluntary severance program."
If a paper is being copy-edited in another country, can it really still be called a "local newspaper"?
However, the wholesale relocation of newspapers to India or any other country is still unlikely. Most newspaper owners are well aware that to provide news to their communities they have to be a part of those communities. Running a newspaper is difficult enough without having to consider time-zone differences when chasing a story.
Early reports on outsourcing indicate that it is not always plane sailing. However, we will have to wait and see how these newspapers fare in their efficiency drive. Maybe this innovation will prove successful.
Source: The Eureka Reporter
Posted in :
Related Entries
- US: Orange County Register launches Kindle edition
- UK: News International titles most popular amongst business readers
- The Future of Investigative Journalism Part 2: Pulitzer prize winner Lowell Bergman - "It is at its root a non-profit activity"
- Online newspaper distributor Newspaper Direct lets users comment on articles
- India: Daily Thanthi unveil Mumbai edition
0 TrackBacks
Listed below are links to blogs that reference this entry: Opinion: Where do we draw the line with outsourcing?.
TrackBack URL for this entry: http://www.editorsweblog.org/mt/mt-tb.cgi/7136


local news paper are in the unique situation where they cannot "sell" their product in ASIA-PAC(India etc). While outsourcing opens up new markets for technology and product companies, newspapers face a daunting challenge.
Local newspapers were great (but limited) monopolies for local news. But with internet, NYT/BBC/CNN etc are just one click away and the local papers don't have level playing field to compete. this is but natural and inevitable.
A brilliant observation indeed! The fleeting growth of outsourcing is sometimes alarming but we cannot ignore the reality of how it has aided the growth of companies worldwide.
I guess companies just have to discern which business processes are wise to outsource and which aren't.