Football World Cup: news vs. entertainment, Europe vs. America
Today is a very important day for the future of sport news. Because FIFA has accepted to remove all restrictions about online coverage - but not for mobile phones - of the Football World Cup (to be held in Germany in June 2006), there is now a major hope that the same scenario will happen for the 2008 Olympic games and that national sport leagues will limit their demands for restrictions.
What are the main lessons of this victory for press freedom against pure commercial interests:
1) all press organisations were united behind the World Association of Newspapers; from news agencies (AFP, Reuters...) to international organisations (ENPA in Europe), to national organisations such as ASNE, the American organisation of editors. When football is a major sport - as in Brazil or Germany -, news organisations also rallied and discussed the legal basis of so many restrictions.
2) football/soccer is considered as public news and not as "private entertainment". As journalists, we have the duty to inform, not to cover such events as the sponsors would like us to. Because sport is news, sport rights owners have limited possibilities to impose restrictions on the events' coverage. Without being schematic, every limitation can be considered as censorship, but until now commercial interests were successful to multiply restrictions (see the football Premier League story in the UK).
3) The FIFA-WAN agreement will have great consequences on some European national agreements (restrictions on stories, photos, scores until the end of the match, sponsors' logos imposed in some pictures...)and maybe the NBA in the US. The WAN-FIFA agrrement is a great encouragement for all news organisations that are struggling against huge commercial interests: now there is a precedent and these organisations can say to sponsors and sport rights owners "why don't do act as FIFA?"
4) last conclusion is that the FIFA-WAN agreement can be seen as a successful European process (even if the stakes are worldwide). FIFA is based in Zurich, Geneva, with very strong European members and WAN is based in Paris, also with strong European members. The two organisations evolve in an environment where news values are still stronger than commercial interests and any lawsuit to a European court would have been very difficult for sport rights owners. I am not sure that if the negociation had occured in an American context the conclusion would have been the same.
And now, what is the next challenge for news organisations? To get for the mobile phone coverage what was obtained for the web-online coverage. In the future, there will be no difference for any user, but at the moment mobile phone users will access to the FIFA World Cup real time coverage only through FIFA sponsors or licensed networks!
Source: WAN-FIFA press release
As a result of the negociation with FIFA, the World Association of Newspapers (WAN) has created a Sports Media Working Group to examine the issue as numerous other sports bodies focus on selling internet and broadcast rights and place increasing restrictions on newspaper coverage of events. The committee is comprised of directors of national newspaper associations that are members of WAN.
0 TrackBacks
Listed below are links to blogs that reference this entry: Football World Cup: news vs. entertainment, Europe vs. America.
TrackBack URL for this entry: http://www.editorsweblog.org/mt/mt-tb.cgi/5816







Hello Sir,
My name is Coach Dayo Faleyimu from Nigeria.
I coach a Grassroot club living in Nigeria.
Pls i need your help for some Traing materials such as FOOTBALL,JERSEYS,TRACK SUITS,BOOTS AND TRAINING MATERIAS etc.
Sir i will be very happy if you can help me with any of this.
Here is my contact number +2348028163187
Yours is Sport
Coach Dayo
I'm not sure, that somebody will help. But I have one advice: search in Google. Everything shold be.
PLEASE I AM SEEKING FOR AN EUROPEAN AGENCIES THAT COULD ASSIST IN HELP LINKING ME TO ENHANCE MY FOOTBALL CAREERS.
Good Day Sir,
My name is Ogbonna Donald Ebuka ,I'm a skillful up coming star with the potential of becoming one of the best in soccer, A 16 year old Nigerian i am desperately in need of an Agent and a Club ,Precisely all in your country, Sir, I so much have the confidence that if you grant my desire I'll make you to be very proud.
I'm waiting your reply Sir.
THANKS
Ogbonna Donald Ebuka
lordpuma_yours@yahoo.com